Why do my new Hacker News account’s comments show as [dead]?
[dead] means Hacker News killed the comment. Its FAQ says that is done by software, user flags or moderators, and dead comments aren’t shown to other readers unless they turn on showdead in their profile. A new account can lose every comment this way: all six of mine died in October 2026.
By Edward Yen, maker of Akoe ·
What happened to mine
I made a Hacker News account on October 1, 2026. Its first comment went out 53 seconds later and two more within four minutes. Each replied to a founder’s post, named my product and linked to it. Two days later I posted three more with no link, written to build up the account, all within a minute.
All six are dead. Five also show [flagged], which HN’s FAQ says means users flagged them as breaking the guidelines or not belonging on HN. None of the six showed up in HN’s search. On October 13 the account still had 1 karma point and all six were still dead.
What HN’s rules say
- “Please don’t use HN primarily for promotion. It’s ok to post your own stuff part of the time, but the primary use of the site should be for curiosity.” My first three comments were all about my own product, on an account with no other history.
- “Don’t post generated text or AI-edited text. HN is for conversation between humans.”
- A new account’s username shows in green, so readers can see it’s new.
- Readers with enough karma can vouch for a dead comment, and when enough of them do, it’s restored.
HN doesn’t say which of software, flags or moderators killed each comment, or what a new account may post. So what my six had in common (a brand-new account, a few comments close together, half of them about my product) is what happened to one account, not a rule HN publishes. HN’s FAQ and guidelines were read on October 13, 2026.
What to do
- See what others see: sign out and open the thread. If your comment isn’t there, it’s dead.
- If you think it was killed by mistake, email hn@ycombinator.com. HN asks people not to post on the site about it.
- Don’t delete it and post it again. HN’s guidelines ask you not to.
- Use the account the way HN asks: comment on what you find interesting, and bring up your own product only part of the time. Write every comment yourself.
- HN has no direct messages. To reach someone, use the email in their profile, if they published one.